Element = Lattice = Model = Element: Nb Lattice: hcp Model: SNAP_LiChenZheng_2019_NbTaWMo__MO_560387080449_000 Computed model cutoff of 4.701199977844981 Angstroms Computed isolated atomic energy of 7.809763407469961 eV for species Nb ============================================================================== ============================================================================== Starting optimization to find optimum lattice constant 'a' with c/a fixed to sqrt(8/3) ============================================================================== ============================================================================== Attempting to perform relaxation using initial lattice constant guess of a = 1.0 Angstroms (c/a fixed at sqrt(8/3)) Optimization terminated successfully. Current function value: -30.763042 Iterations: 40 Function evaluations: 85 Results for this minimization: a = 2.9745796199888033, total energy = -30.763042173971595 Attempting to perform relaxation using initial lattice constant guess of a = 1.125 Angstroms (c/a fixed at sqrt(8/3)) Optimization terminated successfully. Current function value: -30.763042 Iterations: 39 Function evaluations: 83 Results for this minimization: a = 2.974579616077243, total energy = -30.763042173971595 Attempting to perform relaxation using initial lattice constant guess of a = 1.25 Angstroms (c/a fixed at sqrt(8/3)) Optimization terminated successfully. Current function value: -30.763042 Iterations: 39 Function evaluations: 82 Results for this minimization: a = 2.974579613772221, total energy = -30.76304217397159 Attempting to perform relaxation using initial lattice constant guess of a = 1.375 Angstroms (c/a fixed at sqrt(8/3)) Optimization terminated successfully. Current function value: -30.763042 Iterations: 38 Function evaluations: 81 Results for this minimization: a = 2.974579619616277, total energy = -30.76304217397159 Attempting to perform relaxation using initial lattice constant guess of a = 1.5 Angstroms (c/a fixed at sqrt(8/3)) Optimization terminated successfully. Current function value: -30.763042 Iterations: 39 Function evaluations: 83 Results for this minimization: a = 2.97457960546017, total energy = -30.763042173971588 Attempting to perform relaxation using initial lattice constant guess of a = 1.625 Angstroms (c/a fixed at sqrt(8/3)) Optimization terminated successfully. Current function value: -30.763042 Iterations: 37 Function evaluations: 78 Results for this minimization: a = 2.9745796207338593, total energy = -30.76304217397159 Attempting to perform relaxation using initial lattice constant guess of a = 1.75 Angstroms (c/a fixed at sqrt(8/3)) Optimization terminated successfully. Current function value: -30.763042 Iterations: 37 Function evaluations: 78 Results for this minimization: a = 2.9745796173810963, total energy = -30.76304217397159 Attempting to perform relaxation using initial lattice constant guess of a = 1.875 Angstroms (c/a fixed at sqrt(8/3)) Optimization terminated successfully. Current function value: -30.763042 Iterations: 37 Function evaluations: 76 Results for this minimization: a = 2.974579613073729, total energy = -30.76304217397159 Attempting to perform relaxation using initial lattice constant guess of a = 2.0 Angstroms (c/a fixed at sqrt(8/3)) Optimization terminated successfully. Current function value: -30.763042 Iterations: 37 Function evaluations: 77 Results for this minimization: a = 2.9745796173810986, total energy = -30.76304217397159 Attempting to perform relaxation using initial lattice constant guess of a = 2.125 Angstroms (c/a fixed at sqrt(8/3)) Optimization terminated successfully. Current function value: -30.763042 Iterations: 35 Function evaluations: 73 Results for this minimization: a = 2.974579619057478, total energy = -30.76304217397159 Attempting to perform relaxation using initial lattice constant guess of a = 2.25 Angstroms (c/a fixed at sqrt(8/3)) Optimization terminated successfully. Current function value: -30.763042 Iterations: 38 Function evaluations: 81 Results for this minimization: a = 2.9745796164963387, total energy = -30.76304217397159 Attempting to perform relaxation using initial lattice constant guess of a = 2.375 Angstroms (c/a fixed at sqrt(8/3)) Optimization terminated successfully. Current function value: -30.763042 Iterations: 35 Function evaluations: 76 Results for this minimization: a = 2.9745796248316747, total energy = -30.76304217397159 Attempting to perform relaxation using initial lattice constant guess of a = 2.5 Angstroms (c/a fixed at sqrt(8/3)) Optimization terminated successfully. Current function value: -30.763042 Iterations: 34 Function evaluations: 73 Results for this minimization: a = 2.9745796099305153, total energy = -30.76304217397159 Attempting to perform relaxation using initial lattice constant guess of a = 2.625 Angstroms (c/a fixed at sqrt(8/3)) Optimization terminated successfully. Current function value: -30.763042 Iterations: 34 Function evaluations: 73 Results for this minimization: a = 2.974579627811909, total energy = -30.763042173971595 Attempting to perform relaxation using initial lattice constant guess of a = 2.75 Angstroms (c/a fixed at sqrt(8/3)) Optimization terminated successfully. Current function value: -30.763042 Iterations: 34 Function evaluations: 72 Results for this minimization: a = 2.974579616542906, total energy = -30.763042173971595 Attempting to perform relaxation using initial lattice constant guess of a = 2.875 Angstroms (c/a fixed at sqrt(8/3)) Optimization terminated successfully. Current function value: -30.763042 Iterations: 33 Function evaluations: 71 Results for this minimization: a = 2.9745796229224664, total energy = -30.763042173971595 Attempting to perform relaxation using initial lattice constant guess of a = 3.0 Angstroms (c/a fixed at sqrt(8/3)) Optimization terminated successfully. Current function value: -30.763042 Iterations: 32 Function evaluations: 66 Results for this minimization: a = 2.974579618591815, total energy = -30.763042173971595 Attempting to perform relaxation using initial lattice constant guess of a = 3.125 Angstroms (c/a fixed at sqrt(8/3)) Optimization terminated successfully. Current function value: -30.763042 Iterations: 33 Function evaluations: 70 Results for this minimization: a = 2.974579613583046, total energy = -30.763042173971595 Attempting to perform relaxation using initial lattice constant guess of a = 3.25 Angstroms (c/a fixed at sqrt(8/3)) Optimization terminated successfully. Current function value: -30.763042 Iterations: 34 Function evaluations: 73 Results for this minimization: a = 2.974579618312418, total energy = -30.76304217397159 Attempting to perform relaxation using initial lattice constant guess of a = 3.375 Angstroms (c/a fixed at sqrt(8/3)) Optimization terminated successfully. Current function value: -30.763042 Iterations: 35 Function evaluations: 76 Results for this minimization: a = 2.974579622363671, total energy = -30.76304217397159 Attempting to perform relaxation using initial lattice constant guess of a = 3.5 Angstroms (c/a fixed at sqrt(8/3)) Optimization terminated successfully. Current function value: -30.763042 Iterations: 34 Function evaluations: 73 Results for this minimization: a = 2.9745796226779926, total energy = -30.763042173971595 Attempting to perform relaxation using initial lattice constant guess of a = 3.625 Angstroms (c/a fixed at sqrt(8/3)) Optimization terminated successfully. Current function value: -30.763042 Iterations: 35 Function evaluations: 75 Results for this minimization: a = 2.974579617381095, total energy = -30.763042173971588 Attempting to perform relaxation using initial lattice constant guess of a = 3.75 Angstroms (c/a fixed at sqrt(8/3)) Optimization terminated successfully. Current function value: -30.763042 Iterations: 35 Function evaluations: 75 Results for this minimization: a = 2.9745796099305153, total energy = -30.76304217397159 Attempting to perform relaxation using initial lattice constant guess of a = 3.875 Angstroms (c/a fixed at sqrt(8/3)) Optimization terminated successfully. Current function value: -30.763042 Iterations: 36 Function evaluations: 77 Results for this minimization: a = 2.97457961309701, total energy = -30.76304217397159 Attempting to perform relaxation using initial lattice constant guess of a = 4.0 Angstroms (c/a fixed at sqrt(8/3)) Optimization terminated successfully. Current function value: -30.763042 Iterations: 36 Function evaluations: 76 Results for this minimization: a = 2.9745796129107465, total energy = -30.76304217397159 Attempting to perform relaxation using initial lattice constant guess of a = 4.125 Angstroms (c/a fixed at sqrt(8/3)) Optimization terminated successfully. Current function value: -30.763042 Iterations: 36 Function evaluations: 76 Results for this minimization: a = 2.974579612445088, total energy = -30.76304217397159 Attempting to perform relaxation using initial lattice constant guess of a = 4.25 Angstroms (c/a fixed at sqrt(8/3)) Optimization terminated successfully. Current function value: -30.763042 Iterations: 36 Function evaluations: 76 Results for this minimization: a = 2.9745796186616626, total energy = -30.7630421739716 Attempting to perform relaxation using initial lattice constant guess of a = 4.375 Angstroms (c/a fixed at sqrt(8/3)) Optimization terminated successfully. Current function value: -30.763042 Iterations: 38 Function evaluations: 82 Results for this minimization: a = 2.974579630419612, total energy = -30.763042173971588 Attempting to perform relaxation using initial lattice constant guess of a = 4.5 Angstroms (c/a fixed at sqrt(8/3)) Optimization terminated successfully. Current function value: -30.763042 Iterations: 37 Function evaluations: 78 Results for this minimization: a = 2.9745796145056334, total energy = -30.76304217397159 Attempting to perform relaxation using initial lattice constant guess of a = 4.625 Angstroms (c/a fixed at sqrt(8/3)) Optimization terminated successfully. Current function value: -30.763042 Iterations: 37 Function evaluations: 81 Results for this minimization: a = 2.974579619616269, total energy = -30.76304217397159 Attempting to perform relaxation using initial lattice constant guess of a = 4.75 Angstroms (c/a fixed at sqrt(8/3)) Optimization terminated successfully. Current function value: -30.763042 Iterations: 38 Function evaluations: 78 Results for this minimization: a = 2.9745796212926514, total energy = -30.763042173971595 ============================================================================== ============================================================================== Starting optimization with both a and c/a relaxed ============================================================================== ============================================================================== Attempting to perform relaxation using initial lattice constant guess of a = [2.97457962] Angstroms and c = 3.885974541335275 = ([1.30639453] * a) Angstroms Optimization terminated successfully. Current function value: -30.773042 Iterations: 75 Function evaluations: 159 Results for this minimization: a = 2.9493872414872486, c = 4.928194054527951, total energy = -30.77304161896748 Attempting to perform relaxation using initial lattice constant guess of a = [2.97457962] Angstroms and c = 4.12884795016873 = ([1.38804419] * a) Angstroms Optimization terminated successfully. Current function value: -30.773042 Iterations: 76 Function evaluations: 157 Results for this minimization: a = 2.9493872375426293, c = 4.928194103937751, total energy = -30.773041618967483 Attempting to perform relaxation using initial lattice constant guess of a = [2.97457962] Angstroms and c = 4.371721359002185 = ([1.46969385] * a) Angstroms Optimization terminated successfully. Current function value: -30.773042 Iterations: 73 Function evaluations: 153 Results for this minimization: a = 2.9493872541110395, c = 4.9281940234337505, total energy = -30.77304161896748 Attempting to perform relaxation using initial lattice constant guess of a = [2.97457962] Angstroms and c = 4.61459476783564 = ([1.5513435] * a) Angstroms Optimization terminated successfully. Current function value: -30.773042 Iterations: 67 Function evaluations: 141 Results for this minimization: a = 2.9493872502132525, c = 4.928194092154884, total energy = -30.77304161896748 Attempting to perform relaxation using initial lattice constant guess of a = [2.97457962] Angstroms and c = 4.857468176669094 = ([1.63299316] * a) Angstroms Optimization terminated successfully. Current function value: -30.773042 Iterations: 67 Function evaluations: 142 Results for this minimization: a = 2.949387252095584, c = 4.928194062084392, total energy = -30.773041618967483 Attempting to perform relaxation using initial lattice constant guess of a = [2.97457962] Angstroms and c = 5.10034158550255 = ([1.71464282] * a) Angstroms Optimization terminated successfully. Current function value: -30.773042 Iterations: 66 Function evaluations: 137 Results for this minimization: a = 2.9493872504650924, c = 4.928194041795583, total energy = -30.77304161896748 Attempting to perform relaxation using initial lattice constant guess of a = [2.97457962] Angstroms and c = 5.343214994336005 = ([1.79629248] * a) Angstroms Optimization terminated successfully. Current function value: -30.773042 Iterations: 68 Function evaluations: 144 Results for this minimization: a = 2.949387261461793, c = 4.9281940534837805, total energy = -30.77304161896748 Attempting to perform relaxation using initial lattice constant guess of a = [2.97457962] Angstroms and c = 5.58608840316946 = ([1.87794214] * a) Angstroms Optimization terminated successfully. Current function value: -30.773042 Iterations: 73 Function evaluations: 150 Results for this minimization: a = 2.9493872449740595, c = 4.9281940448003905, total energy = -30.773041618967476 Attempting to perform relaxation using initial lattice constant guess of a = [2.97457962] Angstroms and c = 5.828961812002914 = ([1.95959179] * a) Angstroms Optimization terminated successfully. Current function value: -30.773042 Iterations: 70 Function evaluations: 154 Results for this minimization: a = 2.949387253911139, c = 4.928194043545146, total energy = -30.773041618967483 ============================================================================== ============================================================================== Finished with optimization ============================================================================== ============================================================================== Final lattice Constants: a = 2.9493872375426293 Angstroms, c = 4.928194103937751 Angstroms, c/a = 1.670921 Total energy: -30.773041618967483 eV Cohesive energy: -7.693260404741871 eV/atom ============================================================================== ==============================================================================